Former Steelers quarterback Charlie Batch believes Aaron Rodgers has earned a bigger deal, but his future in Pittsburgh now hangs on a financial standoff.
Rodgers is coming off a strong first season with the Steelers, yet uncertainty continues to surround whether he will return for another year.
With no decision announced, the situation has become one of the biggest talking points of the offseason. Batch’s view cuts straight to the core issue. This is no longer about performance, but price.
Charlie Batch backs Aaron Rodgers in contract debate
On BIGPLAY Pittsburgh, Batch argued Rodgers has already outplayed his current value.
“When it comes to Aaron, this is a guy who outplayed his contract. I will stand by this. I may be the only one saying this at this particular point,” Batch said.
He added: “This decision comes down to money. The Steelers would like him to come back, but it’s not going to be at the $13 million number.”
That stance reflects Rodgers’ 2025 season, where he threw for 3,322 yards, 24 touchdowns, and just seven interceptions while leading Pittsburgh to an AFC North title.
Despite that production, his contract situation remains uncertain. Reports indicate the Steelers want him back, but only at a lower figure than what his camp is seeking. That gap has become the defining issue in negotiations.
Aaron Rodgers return to the Steelers could cost $30 million
Rodgers has yet to confirm whether he will return for a 22nd NFL season, with the decision expected before the NFL Draft as Pittsburgh wait for clarity.
“I’m sure Aaron, and I have not spoken to him, but I’m sure his representatives are wanting something closer to $30 [million], and you hope that, somewhere, you meet in the middle,” Batch continued.
He concluded: “If they’re able to do so, Aaron will be back. If not, he’s gonna walk away and say, ‘I’m done.’ That’s why you have not heard his decision.”
Rodgers is also weighing retirement, adding another layer to the delay. That explains why no timeline has been firmly set.
For now, everything points to one conclusion. If the financial gap is not bridged, the Steelers may have to move on.
Receive exclusive football transfer news and updates twice a week to your mailbox
