The Arnold Palmer Invitational is one of the finest events on the PGA Tour, but it’s not always been a popular stop for players.
Played at Arnie’s house, the tournament serves as a fitting prelude to The Players Championship, which takes place a week later. It’s a brutally difficult challenge, and that’s not always gone down well with players.
Bay Hill’s reputation as one of the most punishing venues on the PGA Tour is well earned, and while many players revere it as a tribute to Arnold Palmer, others have famously criticized its setup for being borderline unfair.
Rory McIlroy was among those players in 2022, when many players felt the setup had crossed the line.
Why Rory McIlroy felt ‘punch drunk’ after playing Bay Hill in 2022
In 2022, Bay Hill got the better of McIlroy. He led after round one, then shot 72-76-76 in the next three rounds, and was beaten by the brutally tough golf course.
After the tournament, the Northern Irishman slammed the difficulty of the golf course. He said, “I feel punch drunk. The weekend, it’s like crazy golf. You just don’t get rewarded for good shots. I’m hitting good shots.
“I’m swinging the club well. I’m chipping well. I’m putting well. But it can knock your confidence whenever the conditions are like this.
“I don’t mind golf courses being penal when you miss, but it’s not rewarding good shots. I think that’s where it starts to get across the line. I think as well the frustration is, it’s a carbon copy of what’s happened the last three years here.”
“I think it’s just a golf-course setup issue and maybe just trying to make it a little less penal when you miss, I guess. Or not even less penal when you miss. I don’t mind golf courses being penal when you miss, but it’s not rewarding good shots. I think that’s where it starts to get across the line.
“They need to do something about it. There’s a lot of guys that sort of stay away this week to get ready for next week.”
In fairness to McIlroy, he wasn’t the only one to complain. Adam Scott said he had “nothing good to say” about the course, and Tyrrell Hatton called it “brutal”.
Hatton said, “We know the weekends are pretty brutal here. I think the greens get so quick sometimes, pin positions just seem brutal. And it’s just, like I said, you have to play defensively and try your best to get the ball as close as you can.”
Bay Hill doubled down on difficulty despite player complaints
You might think that Bay Hill would make the course slightly easier after the complaints in 2022, but actually, the trend has been the opposite. They have largely doubled down on the difficulty, though they have made specific architectural changes that are a bit of a mixed bag for the players.
While the fairways were widened slightly a few years ago to help with playability, the setup for the tournament itself remains one of the most punishing on the PGA Tour.
The biggest physical change occurred ahead of the 2025 tournament at the iconic par-three 17th. For decades, a beach bunker sat between the green and the lake. This bunker was removed and replaced with a steep bank of thick rough, and the lake was actually extended further into that area.
While some thought this might make the hole easier, since the ball might get stuck in the grass, many pros argued it made it harder. Previously, the bunker would catch a bad shot. Now, if the ball doesn’t stay in that thick rough, it rolls straight into the water.
If it does stay in the rough, the player is left with an almost impossible chip toward a green sloping back toward the lake.
The Course Superintendent, Chris Flynn, has been transparent about moving the course closer to Arnold Palmer’s original vision, which often means removing safety nets. They have removed many of the rough areas that previously acted as backstops in front of bunkers and water hazards.
Without those patches of grass to slow the ball down, shots that are only slightly off-line now have a much higher probability of rolling all the way into a hazard.
So despite complaints from years ago, expect this course to be no easier for these players this weekend.
Receive exclusive football transfer news and updates twice a week to your mailbox
