Pete Crow-Armstrong pulled off one of baseball’s rarest feats on Monday night. The Chicago Cubs outfielder hit for the cycle in a dramatic 5-4 walk-off win over the Colorado Rockies, becoming the first player in MLB to do it during the 2026 season.
He finished 4 for 4 with two RBI and 10 total bases, recording the 13th cycle in Cubs history and the franchise’s first reverse cycle. The most surprising thing about Crow-Armstrong right now may be that he still doesn’t seem convinced he belongs in the National League’s All-Star conversation. “I don’t think I’ve earned it… yet,” he said recently when discussing the early voting results. The numbers increasingly suggest otherwise.
The cycle was only the latest piece of evidence
Monday’s performance grabbed the headlines, and it did not come out of nowhere. Crow-Armstrong has quietly put together one of the most complete seasons of any outfielder in the National League. Following the cycle, the 24-year-old was hitting .277 with an .844 OPS, 13 home runs, 35 RBI and 16 stolen bases through 73 games.
Those numbers alone would put him firmly in the All-Star discussion. What sets Crow-Armstrong apart from many of his peers is that the offensive production is only part of the story.
The offensive breakout has changed everything
For much of his professional career, Crow-Armstrong was viewed as a defense-first player. Scouts loved the speed and the glove, and the open question was always whether the bat would develop enough to make him a true star. This season has answered it. The former first-round pick has turned into a legitimate power-speed threat, pairing 13 home runs with 16 stolen bases while affecting games in several ways.
The offensive consistency has mattered most. Crow-Armstrong has gone from winning games on athleticism alone to becoming one of the most dangerous hitters in the Cubs lineup.
The defense remains elite
Even with slightly lower offensive numbers, Crow-Armstrong would still have a strong case for recognition, because his defense is among the best in baseball. Entering the week he had already piled up 3.9 WAR and plus-7 Defensive Runs Saved, marks that place him among the most valuable outfielders in the National League. The elite center-field defense was always part of the package, and now it is paired with real offensive production, which is the combination that separates good players from stars.
Craig Counsell’s reaction said plenty
The cycle itself came with a memorable twist. After completing it with a seventh-inning single, Crow-Armstrong was immediately picked off first base. “My excitement was a little short-lived,” Cubs manager Craig Counsell joked afterward.
The moment was funny, and it also captured something about Crow-Armstrong’s development. Instead of basking in the accomplishment, the young outfielder zeroed in on the mistake. “I did everything I could to help the team, but I also had a real lapse in focus,” he admitted after the game. That kind of response may be exactly why he keeps improving, treating a historic personal feat as secondary to the way the game played out.
The All-Star debate is becoming harder to ignore
One of the more surprising parts of Crow-Armstrong’s season is that the first wave of All-Star voting did not fully reflect his impact. No Cubs player landed among the top vote-getters at their position despite several strong individual performances, and Crow-Armstrong’s omission stands out even more after Monday night. Cycles are rare, and so is a player producing 13 home runs, 16 stolen bases and elite center-field defense before the middle of June.
Crow-Armstrong may not agree yet
That tension is what makes the conversation interesting. Crow-Armstrong has repeatedly downplayed the attention and suggested he still has more to prove, and that mindset is probably one reason he has become the player the Cubs envisioned when they acquired him from the New York Mets in the Javier Báez trade. At some point, the production becomes impossible to dismiss.
The cycle will be remembered because it was historic, and the bigger story may be that it forced more people to notice what has been happening all season. Crow-Armstrong may not believe he has earned All-Star recognition, and the evidence is getting harder to argue with by the day.
Receive exclusive football transfer news and updates twice a week to your mailbox
