David Hay thinks no John McGinn signing saw Ryan Christie stay at Celtic

John McGinn of Aston Villa during the Sky Bet Championship match between Middlesbrough and Aston Villa at Riverside Stadium on December 01, 2018 in Middlesbrough, England.

Aston Villa signed John McGinn from Hibernian despite reported interest from Brendan Rodgers’s Celtic.

John McGinn of Aston Villa is tackled by Gareth Barry of West Bromwich Albion during the Sky Bet Championship match between West Bromwich Albion and Aston Villa at The Hawthorns on...

David Hay has suggested in The Glasgow Evening Times that had Celtic signed John McGinn from Hibernian before he went to Aston Villa, then Ryan Christie would have moved to Aberdeen.

John McGinn transfer

Villa in the Championship in England signed McGinn from Hibernian in the summer transfer window for a fee reported by The Lancashire Telegraph to be worth £4 million.



Brendan Rodgers’s Celtic, though, were interested in securing the services of the Scotland international midfielder, according to The Daily Record, with the Glasgow giants claimed to have matched the Villans' offer for the 24-year-old.

McGinn has scored two goals and provided four assists in 18 Championship appearances for Villa so far this season, according to WhoScored.

11th November 2018, Tony Macaroni Arena, Livingston, Scotland; Ladbrokes Premiership football, Livingston versus Celtic; Ryan Christie of Celtic brings the ball under control

Ryan Christie stay

Christie returned to Celtic from a successful loan spell at Aberdeen in the summer of 2018 and has established himself as an important player in Rodgers’s team.

The 23-year-old Scotland international midfielder has scored five goals in 11 Scottish Premiership appearances and has played in four Europa League matches for the Bhoys, according to WhoScored.

Interesting comments

Former Celtic midfielder and manager Hay believes that had Celtic signed McGinn, then Christie would have left for Aberdeen.

Hay wrote in The Glasgow Evening Times: “No-one has a crystal ball but I strongly suspect that had McGinn ended up at Celtic this summer then Ryan Christie would probably have headed back to Aberdeen. Who knows?”

7th December 2018, The Hawthorns, West Bromwich, England; EFL Championship football, West Bromwich Albion versus Aston Villa; John McGinn of Aston Villa is pulled back by Gareth Barry of...

Have something to tell us about this article?

Register for ASTON VILLA team updates

Register for HITC Sport - Daily Dispatch