Should Chancel Mbemba regret not joining Celtic from Newcastle United?

Chancel Mbemba of FC Porto looks on during the presentation of the Porto FC players before the Pre-season friendly match between FC Porto and Newcastle at Estadio do Dragao on July 28,...

Scottish Premiership giants Celtic were reportedly keen on signing Newcastle United's Premier League outcast Chancel Mbemba before he joined Porto.

Chancel Mbemba of Newcastle United celebrates scoring his sides second goal during the Sky Bet Championship match between Newcastle United and Barnsley at St James' Park on May 7, 2017 in...

Newcastle United fans always rated Chancel Mbemba very highly but it seemed that Rafa Benitez never really shared that enthusiasm.

Since the Spanish gaffer took over at St James’ Park in 2016, the Congolese centre-back found first-team football hard to come by. The 24-year-old made just seven Premier League starts for The Magpies last season and some of those came in an unfamiliar left-back role when Paul Dummett was injured at the start of the campaign.


So it was no surprise when Mbemba was sold in the summer, joining Primiera Liga champions Porto for £7 million (BBC) after a protracted transfer saga. But did Newcastle get a good deal? And did Celtic, who were linked in May by The Chronicle miss out on a brilliant signing or get a lucky escape instead?


Well, it’s fair to say Mbemba hasn’t exactly shone in Portuguese football so far. A knee injury kept the 24-year-old out of Porto’s team in the opening weeks of the season but he’s struggled for chances even after returning to full fitness.

Porto's defender Mbemba during the Official Presentation of the FC Porto Team 2018

Mbemba has made just one league appearance and that lasted a total of 10 minutes, while he has been left on the bench in three of the last four games.

Suddenly £7 million looks money well earned for Newcastle. And it’s tempting to wonder whether Mbemba would have been better off at Celtic instead.

With Dedryck Boyata seemingly set to leave in 2019 and Filip Benkovic only on loan from Leicester City, Mbemba could’ve been Celtic’s number one centre-back. Instead, he is a bench-warmer at Porto.

Chancel Mbemba of Newcastle United moves away from Phillip Billing during the Premier League match between Huddersfield Town and Newcastle United at John Smith's Stadium on August 20, 2017...

Have something to tell us about this article?

Register for NEWCASTLE UNITED team updates

Register for HITC Sport - Daily Dispatch