Should Scott McKenna choose Aston Villa over Wolves?

Aston Villa fans celebrate during the FA Cup Semi Final between Aston Villa and Liverpool at Wembley Stadium on April 19, 2015 in London, England.

Wolverhampton Wanderers are reportedly battling their local rivals Aston Villa for Aberdeen's Scottish Premiership ace Scott McKenna.

Scott McKenna of Scotland listens to the anthem during the International Friendly match between Hungary and Scotland at Groupama Arena on March 27, 2018 in Budapest, Hungary.

It is a rather hard sell at the moment claiming that Aston Villa would be a better environment for a promising young player than Wolverhampton Wanderers.

After all, Wolves have taken the Premier League by storm since their promotion in the summer; Nuno Espirito Santo leading an ambitious side to the top half while the prospect of European qualification is not out of the question.

Villa, meanwhile, are without a manager and have won once in ten games, having sacked Steve Bruce on Wednesday. Wolves’ Midland neighbours are also 13th in the Championship.


So why should Scott McKenna choose Villa Park over Molineux, with reports in the Sun (30 September, page 59) claiming that both sides are interested in the £10 million-rated Aberdeen centre-back?

Well, there is the matter of regular first-team football.

Scott McKenna of Aberdeen in action during the Pre-Season Friendly between St Johnstone and Aberdeen at McDiarmid Park on July 8, 2018 in Perth, Scotland.

Nuno has shown that he is keen to foster a consistency in selection at Wolves, choosing the same starting XI for all seven top flight games this season. Ryan Bennett, Willy Boly and Connor Coady have been established as their back three for a year now, with Belgian international Leander Dendoncker struggling to get into the team.

Villa, meanwhile, have a lack of options in defence with James Chester their only natural centre-back. So, while McKenna risks being a bench-warmer at Wolves, he could be a hugely important player at Villa Park.

But it remains to be seen whether the Premier League factor is key.

Scotland's Scott McKenna and Mexico's Carlos Salcedo (R) vie for the ball during their international friendly football match at the Azteca stadium in Mexico City, on June 2, 2018. (Photo...

Have something to tell us about this article?

Register for ASTON VILLA team updates

Register for HITC Sport - Daily Dispatch