Nuhiu has impressed in his last two outings for Sheffield Wednesday.
Nuhiu had been out of favour at Hillsborough, but has scored or assisted in each of his last two outings, which have totalled 38 minutes of football.
But while the 28-year-old's endeavours appear to have won around a number of Wednesday supporters, many remain unconvinced that he is the answer for Carlos Carvalhal's under-performing side.
The Owls travel to Norwich City on Saturday, and could be a striker light with Steven Fletcher carrying a knock.
And assuming the in-form Gary Hooper keeps his place in attack, Nuhiu appears to be in a straight battle with Jordan Rhodes to start at Carrow Road.
But has the Kosovan international done enough? Here's what Wednesdayites are saying about him on social media...
Deserves a place in the starting line up.— John Hall (@JohnHal73268106) 6 December 2017
Has to start.— Christopher Hall (@cchall123) 6 December 2017
I love Big Dave, he's made a big impact on the last couple of games and should be involved from the start in a diamond formation.— Chris Eason (@chriseason0628) 6 December 2017
Im sorry CC is losing it just bloody play him he shows more passion than the rest , defenders hate playing against him & he creates space 4 others Hooper & Rhodes with Atty— Paul Clark Homer23 (@homer23) 6 December 2017
Should play more often— Neil Line (@NeilLine4) 6 December 2017
nuhiu will create space Rhodes..tbf nuhiu is ok with ball at feet SumTimes I'd play him Saturday doubt fletch is fit— dale willett (@dalewillett26) 5 December 2017
Think before considering that we should just focus on next game and hopefully Carlos has the sense to start Nuhiu in a 4-3-3— Rich Hargreaves (@rkhargreaves) 7 December 2017
Let him effect the game from the start and maybe we won't be having to come from behind all the time to get a point. Use him for 60mins and let hooper and Rhodes feed off him, go 2 or 3 goals up then revert to possession keep ball. #gottotrysomething #fanswillloveit #nuhiu #wawaw https://t.co/q019wZq1up— Neil Dunne (@ndunne76) 5 December 2017
Slight backwards step relying on that lump. He couldn’t hit a cows arse wi a banjo!— Tim Wild (@TW_SWFC1867) 6 December 2017
Can sort of understand the perspective here. He has done a great job off the bench recently and people have noticed his value which is great. I do have a feeling starting him isn't the answer to our problems though. For the record, always loved Big Dave— Anthony Poole (@AnthonyPoole) 6 December 2017
he's useless, and it doesn't say much for the rest of the strikers when HE is the answer he's good for putting the nets up #wawaw— Lee Widdison (@WIDDY35) 6 December 2017
Should sell him in the window he is useless. May be a great guy, but we need winners— Dean hubery (@hubery_dean) 6 December 2017
Have you heard of someone called Gary Hooper? He turned the game. Not Nuhiu. Utter nonsense this. Nuhiu 69 appearances. 4 goals. Pathetic. He literally tries hard. That’s it.— Steven Cadman (@Easysteve30) 6 December 2017
Clueless. Not just Carlos but above him massively. Only Weds could screw this up. And Nuhiu is a sack of .....— James Coleman (@james_coleman19) 5 December 2017
Nuhiu has been on Wednesday's books since 2013, and has scored or assisted 42 goals in 169 outings - many of which have been as a substitute.
Should Nuhiu start for Sheffield Wednesday at Norwich?