Andy Townsend believes Manchester United should turn to Diego Simeone instead of sticking with Michael Carrick, even if supporters may not embrace his style of football.
United’s direction has again become a talking point as questions linger over whether the club can close the gap on rivals at the top of the Premier League.
Townsend has now offered a clear view on who he thinks could restore a competitive edge at Old Trafford.
Diego Simeone tipped to replace Michael Carrick at Manchester United
The suggestion came as debate continues around Manchester United’s managerial future. Metro reported Andy Townsend urging United to consider Diego Simeone as the man to replace Michael Carrick.
“Out of all of them, the one manager I would like to see at United is Diego Simeone. I think his football and the way his Atletico Madrid team have played is kind of more suited to the Premier League,” Townsend said.
Townsend’s argument centres on practicality rather than flair. Simeone has built Atletico Madrid around discipline, defensive organisation, and relentless intensity, traits that often translate well to the physical demands of English football.
For a United side trying to rediscover consistency and resilience, that approach could provide structure and identity, even if it sacrifices aesthetic appeal.
Andy Townsend warns Diego Simeone’s style may frustrate fans
Townsend acknowledged that Simeone’s appointment would not be universally welcomed by Manchester United supporters. He suggested the stylistic shift might jar with expectations at Old Trafford.
“I don’t think his style of play would please the United fans. They want something more flamboyant,” Townsend continued.
He concluded: “But at the moment, United need to get back on level terms with the likes of City and Liverpool and try to get ahead of Arsenal, I don’t think you want someone who’s talking about the beautiful game.”
The point was clear. Results and competitiveness should take priority over aesthetics. United have watched Manchester City and Liverpool set the pace in recent seasons, while Arsenal have re-established themselves as contenders.
Townsend’s stance suggests that substance must come before spectacle. Simeone may not deliver flowing football, but he would almost certainly bring intensity and defensive steel. The question is whether United’s hierarchy and fan base would accept that trade-off.
Receive exclusive football transfer news and updates twice a week to your mailbox
