Buster Olney recently identified the MLB executives facing the most pressure ahead of the Aug. 3 trade deadline, and it is hard to argue with the one he placed near the top. No front office may be staring down a tougher decision than Detroit Tigers president of baseball operations Scott Harris.
The question sounds simple. Should the Tigers trade Tarik Skubal? Everything underneath it is complicated.
The problem is that Skubal is exactly the player you never want to trade
Organizations spend decades searching for pitchers like Tarik Skubal, and the Tigers found one, then watched him do it again the following season. Skubal enters this deadline as a two-time reigning American League Cy Young winner and one of the most dominant pitchers in baseball.
Even after dealing with injury issues in 2026, he remains one of the sport’s most valuable assets. Pitchers like that are supposed to be the foundation of a franchise rather than names floated on the trade market, and that is what makes Detroit’s situation so uncomfortable.
The standings are forcing the conversation
If the Tigers were leading the AL Central or sitting comfortably in a playoff spot, none of this would come up. Reality has been less kind. Detroit entered mid-June at 29-37, fourth in the division and several games behind the final Wild Card position.
The Tigers are not completely out of the race, and that may be part of the problem. They are close enough to talk themselves into a run and far enough back to make selling a very real possibility. That gray area is where the hardest decisions live.
Every contender would line up for Skubal
Part of Harris’ challenge is grasping just how valuable Skubal would be on the market. The Dodgers, Yankees, Orioles, and Brewers would all call, and so would virtually every other contender with championship aspirations. A healthy Skubal is the kind of pitcher who can completely alter a postseason race, which means the prospect return could be enormous, potentially franchise-altering. That only makes standing pat harder.
The Tigers may never have more leverage than they do right now
This is the part that keeps front-office executives up at night. Skubal is scheduled to become a free agent after the season, and he revealed earlier this year that the Tigers never presented him with a long-term offer during the offseason. Contract discussions are reportedly on hold until after the year, which does not mean he is leaving but does create a lot of risk.
If Detroit keeps Skubal and misses the playoffs, the organization could lose one of baseball’s best pitchers without ever cashing in his trade value. That possibility is what makes Harris’ decision so consequential.
The argument for keeping him is just as compelling
There is a strong case on the other side. Trading Skubal would send a devastating message to a fan base that has spent years waiting for sustainable contention. The Tigers have already endured a lengthy rebuild, and at some point a rebuild has to end and a franchise has to decide it is serious about winning.
Moving a Cy Young winner can easily look like another step backward, even when the long-term logic holds up. And if Detroit unexpectedly catches fire over the next six weeks, selling becomes impossible to justify. That is why Harris cannot make this call today. The standings may ultimately make it for him.
One trade could define an entire front-office tenure
That is why Olney’s assessment resonates. This is more than another deadline transaction. The decision Harris makes on Skubal could shape the Tigers for years. Keeping him is a bet that contention is closer than the standings suggest.
Trading him is a bet that the future matters more than a slim shot at October baseball in 2026. Neither path is comfortable or risk-free, and that is exactly why Scott Harris may be the executive under the most pressure in the sport. Sometimes the hardest decisions involve the players you most want to keep, and Tarik Skubal is one of them. The Tigers just have to decide whether holding on is still the right move.
Receive exclusive football transfer news and updates twice a week to your mailbox
