Brandel Chamblee weighs in on who’s better: Scottie Scheffler or Rory McIlroy

Follow us on Google Discover

Right now, there is no question that Scottie Scheffler and Rory McIlroy are the top two golfers in the world.

The only issue for McIlroy is that Scheffler has been playing at a level above him for quite some time. This is not just a recent trend – it is something that has become clear over the past few years.

Now, Brandel Chamblee has weighed in on the ongoing debate about who is actually the better player.

Scheffler and McIlroy are currently setting the pace for every PGA Tour player out there, with others like Tommy Fleetwood and Xander Schauffele looking to them for inspiration.

But who is the superior golfer? The notoriously outspoken golf analyst has just offered his opinion on that very question.

Brandel Chamblee shares his view on who is better between Scottie Scheffler and Rory McIlroy

The general consensus is that Scheffler is much more consistent than McIlroy, though the 2025 Masters champion’s ‘A+’ game is slightly better than the Open champion’s.

There is no arguing with the fact that the world number one has been putting up numbers over the past few years that we have not seen since Tiger Woods was in his prime.

During an appearance on the 5 Clubs podcast, Chamblee was asked if Scheffler could surpass McIlroy in the all-time rankings by the end of 2026.

He replied: “Well, look, I mean, Rory’s been playing professional golf for almost 20 years.

“You can cherry pick his best year, and he’s not been as good as Scheffler has over the last two years.

“So cherry pick his best year, it could be 2012, it could be 2014, it could be 2019. It could be last year.

“And from a purely statistical standpoint, he’s not been the player that Scottie Scheffler has been the last two years.

“We haven’t seen the likes of Scottie Scheffler, not named Tiger Woods, and what Scottie Scheffler has done the last three years, you know, we could argue is that trend gonna continue?

“What he did in 2023 was unbelievable. He became number one in 2022, but at the end of 2024, would you have said he’s likely to have a better year in 2025?

“You know, common sense would have said, ‘Probably not’.

“But he did. He had a better year in 2025 than he had in 2024. Maybe not from a win standpoint all the way around, but from a statistical standpoint.

“He separated himself to a degree that only Tiger Woods has been able to match, and Tiger Woods only exceeded the degree to which Scottie Scheffler separated himself last year three times in his career, only three times.

“Scottie Scheffler was about a shot last year, better than Rory.

“He was about a half a shot the year before, better than Xander Schauffele. I say Rory, because Rory was number two in scoring average. And the year before it was Xander Schauffele.

“The year before that, he was about two tenths of a shot better than Rory McIlroy.

“So he’s continuing to distance himself from his competition as time’s going on, and he gets into his physiological prime the same way Tiger Woods did.”

The numbers back up what Chamblee is saying. Over the past few seasons, there has not been much of a comparison between McIlroy and Scheffler when it comes to statistics.

Although the 36-year-old is sure to secure more major victories before retiring, he probably will not be able to match Scheffler’s remarkably consistent rate of winning.