Milner's late penalty made it five wins in a row as the Reds came back from 1-0 down at half time.
Newcastle followed up their dramatic win over Norwich with a much more low key 1-0 win over Rotherham.
The unfortunate feat occurred twice during Saturday's fixtures, with two sides missing two penalties, and we are not short of past examples.
The striker has five goals in five league games for Everton this season.
As Watford drew 2-2 at home to Bournemouth in the Premier League, we take a look at the five things we learned from the game.
Aston Villa lost against Preston North End in the Championship on Saturday.
Manchester City's supporters responded with disappointment to Pep's first defeat in all competitions, as City lost 2-0 away to Spurs.
Harry Kane congratulated Dele Alli and plenty of other Spurs players were very pleased.
Newcastle United are currently third in the Championship table.
The Newcastle United forward has been linked with a move to Rangers.
With Arsenal's campaign about to get underway, what can we take from their pre-season? Who was their best player? When was their best performance?
The Toffees defence is uncertain as the Premier League approaches, with transfer rumours in and out of the club swirling throughout the media.