West Ham flop also ranked highly, or lowly dependent on your view - and should arguably be the worst.
No Chelsea, Liverpool or Manchester United stars feature, while a Burnley summer signing takes the honour ahead of Tottenham Hotspur and Arsenal players.
Smalling was the senior defender in a youthful looking back line at the Emirates Stadium for Manchester United.
Manchester United midfielder Ander Herrera has been linked - again - with an exit; this time to Bayern Munich.
Christian Eriksen was on fire for Tottenham Hotspur against Hull City in the Premier League on Sunday.
QPR are reportedly interested in Porto defender Rolando - but so are Roma.
Newcastle United should go all-out to try and sign Memphis Depay from PSV in January.
Steven Gerrard and Martin Skrtel offered little to the Liverpool cause during their 3-1 Premier League defeat to Crystal Palace.
What can be learnt from matchday 18 of the Championship?
If Dinamo Zagreb midfielder Marcelo Brozovic is coming to the Emirates Stadium in the near future then it won't be on the cheap.