The Sheffield Wednesday goalkeeper is excelling in Keiren Westwood's absence.
But Wildsmith must not dwell on his latest error - after all, he was not the only Wednesday player culpable against the Blues - and should instead seek inspiration from a flawless January in his ongoing quest to become the Owls' permanent number one.
According to Opta, the 22-year-old kept three clean sheets and made 17 saves, including a penalty, in four Championship outings last month - all of which are the most of any goalkeeper in the division.
And it is perhaps no surprise to see Wildsmith consequently named in Whoscored's second tier team of the month - after accruing an impressive average score of 7.5.
So even with the recovering Keiren Westwood and another bright academy product, Cameron Dawson, set to breathe down his neck over the course of the coming weeks, there is little reason yet for Wednesday to panic where Wildsmith is concerned.
Should Wildsmith keep his place for Sheffield Wednesday against old club Barnsley this weekend?