West Ham United FC (@whufc_official) March 3, 2016
Both have been extremely creative in the top flight this season, creating chances galore between them.
While Arsenal fans will defend their German midfielder, though, West Ham supporters will always be keen to argue Payet's superiority considering the fantastic debut season he's enjoyed at Upton Park.
Meanwhile, another fan favourite at Upton Park in Michail Antonio has picked the song he wants supporters to chant for him when West Ham play.
Payet already has a famous song chanted for him by fans. Antonio clearly deserves his own - and may well get one he likes now.
West Ham face Everton this weekend, while the Gunners travel to Tottenham.