The Sky Sports pundit believes this Villa side is even worse than that woeful Sunderland outfit.
Indeed, taking to Twitter after Villa's 6-0 loss to Liverpool, Carragher responded to comments about Mick McCarthy's Sunderland side and the Derby County team that finished bottom in 2007/08.
And the pundit is sticking to his guns - suggesting Aston Villa's dreadful performance against the Reds makes them worse than McCarthy's infamous Sunderland outfit and a Derby side that was doomed from the start.
I was told afterwards that Sunderland & Derby had less points but I can't remember seeing anything as bad as that! https://t.co/8lROlNgSAu— Jamie Carragher (@Carra23) February 14, 2016
Aston Villa remain eight points off safety after their 6-0 drubbing and are seven points behind the current Sunderland side.
While the Black Cats were beating Manchester United and Norwich City earning a point against West Ham, Newcastle United were battered 5-1 by Chelsea and Villa produced their horror show against Liverpool.
It's becoming clear who at least wants to fight for their Premier League status and who doesn't...