Roy Hodgson named his Three Lions team for the upcoming Euro 2016 qualifiers on Thursday afternoon - announced on the FA's official website - with Arsenal's Kieran Gibbs and Southampton's Ryan Bertrand getting the nod ahead of Cresswell.
The selection choices of Hodgson have frustrated Hammers supporters, who feel that Cresswell deserved a call-up.
Gibbs has been Arsenal's second-choice left-back for the entire season so far, while Bertrand has played just one Premier League game since returning from injury.
Cresswell, meanwhile, has impressed in a West Ham shirt for the second season running - and continues to be a mainstay in their side.
The 25-year-old already has 11 appearances under his belt this season campaign, and has starred in Slaven Bilic's side as they have made a promising start to the new campaign.
His good form has not been enough to earn him his first call-up to the national team, though, and many West Ham supporters have been left to ponder what else he has to do to catch Hodgson's eye.
Here is the best reaction from Hammers fans on social media site Twitter to Cresswell's omission.
Kieran Gibbs over Aaron Cresswell? Really. What a joke.— Paul the Blue Alien (@Puffman180) October 1, 2015
How on earth @Aaron_Cresswell dosent get into England squad is a mystery— Kevin Painter (@OfficialKP180) October 1, 2015
Gibbs over Cresswell has to be the most frustrating thing I've ever seen— Peter Swan (@peterswan96) October 1, 2015
Cresswell deserves a call up more than Gibbs. He's had a wonderful year!— Just Banter (@TittleTan_z) October 1, 2015
To be fair if you're Aaron Cresswell you've got to wonder what you have to do to get some form of recognition— Mark Sheppard (@MarkShep_Lcfc) October 1, 2015
What does Cresswell have to do be in the England squad— Bradley Parker (@parker_bradley) October 1, 2015
HOW DOES CRESSWELL NOT GET INTO THE ENGLAND SQUAD? Way better than Gibbs.— Freddie Embleton (@Fremble111) October 1, 2015
Not a biased view but it baffles me how Bertrand & Gibbs who've hardly played this season get in over West Ham player of year in Cresswell— Kieron Marshall (@MarshallKieron) October 1, 2015
Why on earth is Cresswell not in the England squad? Best English left back and not even in the squad, Roy's big club mentality...— Harry Medhurst (@meddy_whu) October 1, 2015
How does Aaron Cresswell not make the England squad, baffling— Jack Morgan (@JackMorgan_14) October 1, 2015