Why Arsenal and Tottenham interest in Tom Cleverley makes little sense

The two North London clubs are rumoured to want to take Tom Cleverley on a free transfer from Manchester United this summer.

There were high hopes for Tom Cleverley when he broke into Manchester United’s first team.

He was a bright, energetic central midfielder who had the potential to replicate a young Paul Scholes with his neat short passing and his ability to link-up play further up the pitch, as well as both creating and scoring goals.

After breaking into United’s first team back in 2011-12, Cleverley hit the ground running, making himself an established member of the starting eleven after impressive displays in the Community Shield win over Manchester City and the 8-2 thumping of Arsenal.

However, a serious ankle injury caused by a horrific Kevin Davies tackle cut his original breakthrough short and although Cleverley won a Premier League winners medal in 2013, forging a magnificent partnership with Michael Carrick, he was never quite the same player.

When David Moyes took charge, Cleverley lost all confidence and became a major scapegoat for most of United’s on-field issues. It has seen him move on loan to Aston Villa this season, much to the delight of the majority of the United fan-base.

It means that rumoured interest from Arsenal and Tottenham Hotspur, per Sky Sports, is extremely surprising, considering Cleverley’s past at a top Premier League club.

He proved during his three seasons in United’s first team that he is not good enough to hold down a regular slot in a team like that. He is too negative with his passing and rarely weighs in with goals or assists.

Although value is there as he is available on a free transfer, the two North London sides would be making a mistake in bringing him to their club.

After a season out of the spotlight at Old Trafford, Cleverley appears to have found his feet again and has shown that a club like Villa, who look like finishing just below mid-table, is about his level.

Cleverley is not a top-class midfielder but he is by no means a poor footballer and he should remain at Villa Park to continue his revival next season.

Register for MANCHESTER UNITED team updates

Register for ARSENAL team updates

Register for TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR team updates

Register for ASTON VILLA team updates

Register for HITC Sport - Daily Dispatch