Tories are on hunt for anti-Labour mouthpieces, says Balls

Mouth Julia Freeman Woolpert

Ed Balls, the shadow chancellor, has accused the Tories of trying to orchestrate criticism of Labour after the boss of Boots suggested that Ed Miliband as prime minister would be a catastrophe.

He joined other senior Labour figures in dismissing the comments of Stefano Pessina, the acting chief executive of the pharmacy chain, saying it would “stick in the craw” that someone who does not pay tax in Britain was telling people in the country how to vote.

Balls then suggested that the Conservatives would try to influence voters by persuading more high-profile people to speak out against Labour in the coming campaign.

Speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, he said: “I would think in the next three months we going to have a number of people brought forward by the Conservatives, whether it’s Gary Barlow or Mr Pessina, saying ‘Don’t vote Labour.’ The idea that somebody who doesn’t pay tax in Britain telling people how to vote will stick in the craw.”

Balls also pointed out that Pessina had criticised only one policy, and that was the threat of leaving the EU – something only likely under the Conservatives or Ukip.

The Tories insist that they had nothing to do with Pessina’s comments but George Osborne took the unusual step of providing a direct quote highlighting the businessman’s stance. The party has previously been known to approach business people to speak out on sensitive political issues such as the Scottish independence referendum.

Douglas Alexander, the head of Labour’s election campaign, had already described Pessina’s comments as “rubbish”, while Chuka Umunna, the shadow business secretary, said the electorate was unlikely to listen to someone who does not live or pay tax in the UK.

Pessina lives in Monte Carlo, with a fortune estimated at £7.5bn. Boots was targeted by tax campaigners when it moved its formal tax residence from Britain to Switzerland following Pessina’s private equity-backed buyout in 2007. When Pessina merged Boots with US group Walgreens in 2014, there were plans to move its headquarters from the US to Switzerland for tax reasons, although the idea was abandoned after a US political row and a potential customer backlash.

The weekend row started with Pessina, the 74-year-old acting chief executive of Walgreens Boots Alliance, saying that if Labour politicians acted in the way that they spoke “it would be a catastrophe”.

In an interview with the Sunday Telegraph, Pessina said: “The problem is would they [Labour] act that way or not? One thing is to threaten and to shout but it is completely different to be in charge and to manage the country day-to-day ... [and if they did it would be] not helpful for business, not helpful for the country and in the end it probably won’t be helpful for them.”

Pessina, whose company has 2,500 shops and employs 70,000 staff in Britain, declined to say which policies he particularly objected to but there has been previous criticism by business executives of Labour promises to reintroduce a 50p top rate of income tax, freeze prices in the energy sector and impose restrictions on the size of high street banks.

A spokesman for Walgreens Boots Alliance attempted to clarify Pessina’s comments on Sunday night.

He said: “The comments made by Stefano Pessina were a small part of a much larger conversation and have been taken out of context. Stefano Pessina was expressing his personal views only and is not campaigning against Ed Miliband or the Labour party.

“Indeed, he previously held good relationships with the Labour governments under Tony Blair and Gordon Brown, as well as the current coalition government led by David Cameron and Nick Clegg.”

Powered by article was written by Rowena Mason and Terry Macalister, for The Guardian on Monday 2nd February 2015 09.55 Europe/London © Guardian News and Media Limited 2010