The Premier League's most commanding goalkeeper? Surprise answer

You might expect leading lights from Chelsea, Manchester City or Arsenal to be the Premier League's most commanding goalkeeper, but you would be wrong.

Claiming high balls fed into the box may be a dying art in modern football, but there are still those who would rather claim a cross than throw a wild punch at it.

Some goalkeepers positively thrive on the feel of leather on glove, with there always the risk when going with the knuckles rather than the palms that an attempted clearance will become a costly flap.

It has been suggested down the years that the reluctance to take control of high crosses or set-pieces is an approach born out of continental Europe or South America, with British shot-stoppers placing greater emphasis on controlling their penalty area.

Looking at this season’s Premier League statistics, there is little to back up those claims.

In fact, the man with the safest hands in the business when it comes to the collection of high balls may surprise you.

We are not talking about a leading light from Chelsea, Manchester City or Arsenal, or even Southampton’s tightest defence in the English top-flight.

Instead, we are dealing with a goalkeeper who has faced criticism in the past for his lack of composure and one who spent the best part of seven years filling back-up duties at Emirates Stadium.

  TeamTotal High ClaimGood High ClaimCross Not ClaimedSavesAppearancesMins Played
Lukasz Fabianski Swansea 35 35 1 31 11 990
Thibaut Courtois Chelsea 26 26 0 25 11 924
Julian Speroni C. Palace 22 22 6 29 11 955
Brad Guzan Aston Villa 20 19 1 34 11 990
Fraser Forster Southampton 19 17 0 18 11 990
Tim Howard Everton 19 18 2 23 11 990
Tim Krul Newcastle 17 16 2 24 11 990
Robert Green QPR 15 14 0 41 10 900
Asmir Begovic Stoke 14 14 0 14 11 990
Ben Foster West Brom 13 12 0 27 10 900
Joe Hart Man City 13 13 1 23 10 900
Vito Mannone Sunderland 13 12 2 30 9 810
Hugo Lloris Tottenham 12 12 0 31 11 990
Adrián West Ham 11 10 1 38 11 990
Wojciech Szczesny Arsenal 11 10 1 27 11 990
Allan McGregor Hull City 10 10 0 19 6 540
Tom Heaton Burnley 10 10 0 33 11 990
David de Gea Man Utd 8 8 1 24 11 990
Simon Mignolet Liverpool 7 6 3 29 11 990
Kasper Schmeichel Leicester 4 4 0 35 10 900

Swansea City’s Lukasz Fabianski sits at the top of the Premier League tree, with the Poland international taking considerably more high balls than any of his rivals and failing with only one effort when taking the aerial route.

It comes as something of a surprise to find the former Arsenal man leading the way as he is among the least commanding Premier League keepers to look at. He is not a towering Fraser Forster or Thibaut Courtois or a sprightly David de Gea or Hugo Lloris.

It appears as though Fabianski has quite a spring in his step, though, and provides a reassuring presence behind Garry Monk’s back four at the Liberty Stadium.

Picking out a few of the other numbers to jump out on the list, United and Liverpool supporters may be slightly concerned, but probably not all that surprised, to find that De Gea and Simon Mignolet are not the most prolific when it comes to high catches, while Crystal Palace followers would expect better from club legend Julian Speroni after seeing six attempted claims pass him by.

FIFA World Cup 2018FIFA 2018 World Cup Russia - click here for all of our coverage...

Register for CHELSEA team updates

Register for ARSENAL team updates

Register for MANCHESTER UNITED team updates

Register for MANCHESTER CITY team updates

Register for HITC Sport - Daily Dispatch