Suso scored in extra time before playing his role in a dramatic penalty shootout.
It looked as if he had scored the winner only for Patrick Bamford to equalise from the penalty spot for the visitors to take the game into a marathon penalty shootout.
The Spaniard - who made his first appearance following a loan spell at La Liga side Almeria - also stepped up twice to take a spot kick as the Reds won 14-13 on penalties in a game that won't be forgotten about easily.
As well as pleasing performances from youngsters Jordan Rossiter and Jordan Williams, there was plenty of reaction to Suso's cameo, and many fans on twitter would like to see the Spaniard used on more occasions.
He played several games during Brendan Rodgers' first season in charge, but it remains to be seen if he gets many more opportunities this season after being heavily linked with a move to Serie A giants AC Milan.
Here is what a few fans had to say:
Not sure why suso doesnt play more often thought he was excellent this morning and deserves to play this weekend + another contract #keephim— Andy Olivier (@Livers4life) September 24, 2014
Well done to Suso as well. Came on & took his goal well on his wrong foot. Hoping he'd start instead of Sterling. #LFC— The Lobster (@AniketShah92) September 24, 2014
Suso looked good when he came on last night, defo a player there, don't know why Rodgers won't give him a go— John Wilson (@willolfc78) September 24, 2014
One thing i did learn about last nights match is that Suso deserves more game time. He looked good when he came on.— adrian day (@redcatz12) September 24, 2014
On current form of Coutinho & Markovic I can't understand why Suso doesn't get chances starting in the league ⚽️